United States › Northeast › New York › Sullivan County
Local News Report In Sullivan County, New York, Sep 29, 2026
Permanent address · /ny/sullivan-county/2026/09/29/the-hudson-valleys-best-pizzeria-wants-review-from-dave-portnoy-35264
Status
Reported, not yet confirmed
Independent sources
3
First seen
Sep 29, 7:25 PM EDT
updated Oct 2, 10:01 AM EDT
Topic
Local News
Reported by WPDA and WZAD, not yet confirmed.
Sources · Copies Of One Story Count Once
What Did Dave Portnoy Rate Pipinelli's Pizza in Poughkeepsie? · WPDASep 29, 7:25 PM EDT
The Hudson Valley’s “Best” Pizzeria Wants Review From Dave Portnoy · WPDASep 30, 6:00 PM EDT
Fishkill Pizza Shop Scores Big From Barstool's Dave Portnoy · WZADOct 2, 5:51 AM EDT
Fishkill Pizza Shop Scores Big From Barstool's Dave Portnoy · WPDA · the same story as an earlier source: it counts onceOct 2, 10:01 AM EDT
How It Unfolded
Official Confirmation
No official source confirms this yet. It is reported, not confirmed.
This map needs WebGL, which this browser does not offer. What it shows is on this page as text.
Sullivan County and its neighbours, as they are right now. The event is placed on the county; it is not drawn as a point.
How We Decided
Oct 1, 4:20 PM EDTHeld: One source so far, and no official source confirms it yet.Oct 3, 6:25 AM EDTPublished: Two or more independent sources reported it.NextConfirmed when an official source agrees.